Deciding Which Saber UPDATED 5/31

[r0nin89]

I am preparing different sabers to send in to Random Sabers to have machine. I am going to have it made into a stunt saber that can be dueled with. There in lies my problem, I dont want to spend $50- $125 and get it an say I should have done my other design. So I'll post pictures of the two I have made so far in gmax and update with more I come up with later on. PLEASE POST YOUR OPINION!

My two originals:

www.imagedump.com/index.cgi?pick=setandget&tp=257075&poll_id=0&category_id=19&warned=y

My second two:

www.imagedump.com/index.cgi?pick=get&tp=257453

[adam21]

I prefer the one on the left, purely because I don't like the "claws" (for want of a better word) around the emitter on the second one.

[Seda Navilli]

same, i think its very hard to make a saber with claws that doesnt look tacky, but the one on the right seems a bit unbalanced as well, the grip area is far too long. The one on the left however looks pretty good, althought i dont think the emitter would work out well in real life (would look a bit like a torch i think)

[petary791]

I'd go with the one on the left. It's pretty hot.

[petary791]

Alright if you're going for the Sith look, go with number 2 on the second link, but lightside, i'd say go with number 1 on the first link.

I suggest Photobucket or Imageshack instead of the wone you're using too.

[Seda Navilli]

In the second link, I'd go with the one on the right. Alot more balanced

[J'st-Peat]

I am just curious have you heard from the guys at random sabers? My saber was supposed to be done for the movie premeire, the date got pushed back twice. Bought it in Feb, paid it in full when a week before work was supposed to begin so I wouldnt hold up the process that was the middle of april, emailed them and havent heard from them. Its paid for and everything, but still no saber and no contact. I know people have had good experiences with, eventually I am sure I will hear from them, but that is just my two dactaries take it for what its worth!

[Seda Navilli]

Someone else has also had trouble contacting them :S hmmm

[r0nin89]

Hmmm I sent them a gmax file of the first link left saber asking for a price. Its been about 3days and no response.

Pret what a coincident I'm from Pt.Pleasant NJ, my father works in Denville.

[J'st-Peat]

Awesome Ronin....PM me sometime I am the RL state captain for NJ/NYC if you need any costume help dropp me a line more than will to help out!!!!

[Xorren Hedrasii]

first two