Post by kivaanzion on Jun 28, 2005 11:56:27 GMT -5
adavenport said:
qualtotem said:
i like the "there is no emotion there is peace" line ...That's actually the line that I have the most trouble with. "There is no emotion..." sounds a bit too much like suppressing emotions, which overall is a bad thing.
Ok I've really put a lot of thought into why "There is no emotion: there is peace." precisely describes what it means to be a Jedi, and probably why it is first:
People in general are ruled by their emotions. We do things that make us happy. We avoid things, situations, or people that make us uncomfortable, angry, or sad. We put things off because they are tiresome, or boring, or unpleasant. All of this is because of our emotions.
Sometimes we make quick, irrational decisions because of what we "feel" rather than what would be the logical course of action. Have you ever found yourself saying "It seemed like a good idea at the time"? It usually happens when someone makes a short-sighted choice because they feel the need for instant gratification without considering the consequences of their actions first (something my teenage step-daughter does far too often
).A Jedi must be able to make life or death decisions (which sometimes hold several lives in the balance) without being blinded by emotions of personal gain or loss. A Jedi also has the power of the Force, which is the ultimate power in the universe (contrary to what Admiral Motti might believe). With that power comes an equal amount of responsibility.
Therefore the Jedi must feel nothing. It is not about suppressing emotions; it is about having no emotions whatsoever. Only when a Jedi has become completely devoid of emotions can they think clearly and always make the correct decision. A Jedi has no fear of death, or loss, as they are emotions that could cloud their judgment. Their actions are never for personal gain (happiness, gratitude, reward), but are always for the good of other beings.
Consider the scene in TPM when the big fish tries to eat the Gungan sub: Qui-Gon turns around to look and has no expression on his face. Jar-Jar is freaking out (as would most of us be) but both Jedi are calm and at peace. They are able to think of what to do next without being held back by feelings of fear or despair.
Another scene occurs in AOTC when Anakin is levitating the apple in front of Padme and says, "If Master Obi-Wan caught me doing this he would be very grumpy." Why would Obi-Wan be so upset? Because Anakin is showing off his power to Padme in order to impress her. This goes against two things: Anakin must not try to encourage any woman to want to have a relationship with him, and he must not do things for the sole purpose of impressing others (which in turn feeds his own ego).
This is what it means to be a Jedi. To be completely emotionless. To have no possessions (as they lead to feelings of need, jealousy, and greed). To have no relationships (as they can lead to fear of the loss of loved ones). And to have no fear of death (so they will be completely selfless).
Well I guess I've gone on long enough.
