Post by Schph Gochi on May 22, 2005 4:47:53 GMT -5
I have only seen ROTS once so far...at midnight...and after a full day of work ....and a lot of other stresses...my first reaction is:
yuck!
I had a whole cupholder full of Kleenex ....ready to cry...and found that I did not shed a tear....
I am terribly disappointed in ROTS....but...
I was also disappointed the first viewing of PM...and when I went to see it a second time and under different circumstances....I was then blown away by it.
I know this will be the case with ROTS too...there were some things to like...but too many things to NOT like...
Grevious is a cartoon...and annoyed me much more than Jar Jar ever did...
The CG is over done...too much...
Natalie Portman was atrocious (sp?)....wooden as ever...she may know how to act...but she can't act with blue/green screen......and that is what was needed.
The only time I felt a slight tear coming to my eyes was the very end...with Beru and Owen and baby Luke watching the twin suns set....
My big "wow" moment was the horrified look on Anakin's face when the Vader mask came down and "locked" him in the suit....it was a real kick in the gut...Hayden nailed that scene for all it was worth......
I read the novelization before the movie came out...and the movie just didn't do the novelization justice....it looked like Anakin turned very fast...but the novel make the transition much more painful....
yuck!
I had a whole cupholder full of Kleenex ....ready to cry...and found that I did not shed a tear....
I am terribly disappointed in ROTS....but...
I was also disappointed the first viewing of PM...and when I went to see it a second time and under different circumstances....I was then blown away by it.
I know this will be the case with ROTS too...there were some things to like...but too many things to NOT like...
Grevious is a cartoon...and annoyed me much more than Jar Jar ever did...
The CG is over done...too much...
Natalie Portman was atrocious (sp?)....wooden as ever...she may know how to act...but she can't act with blue/green screen......and that is what was needed.
The only time I felt a slight tear coming to my eyes was the very end...with Beru and Owen and baby Luke watching the twin suns set....
My big "wow" moment was the horrified look on Anakin's face when the Vader mask came down and "locked" him in the suit....it was a real kick in the gut...Hayden nailed that scene for all it was worth......
I read the novelization before the movie came out...and the movie just didn't do the novelization justice....it looked like Anakin turned very fast...but the novel make the transition much more painful....
